Hardcore for Nerds

"Why sneer at the intellectuals?"*
punk music, left politics, and cultural history - previously found here.
contact: gabbaweeks[at]gmail.com (sorry, no promos/submissions, thanks) or ask
Dublin, Ireland. 24, male, history graduate
HFN | HFN 2011 HFN 2010 hfn2k9 HRO 2k9 Hoover Genealogy Project | Hitler Runoff | @HC4N
*from the title of a review of Arthur Koestler's Arrival and Departure by Michael Foot, Evening Standard, Nov. 26, 1943.
Nov 05
Permalink
fleetfootedfox:

tristn:

“The final world-shattering salvo of the Loudness War”: Here’s the waveform of the first minute of Sleigh Bells “Crown on the Ground”.

Ohmygod.  It’s clipping-as-distortion-effect.

but clipping (or, at least, serious deterioration of sound quality) is already an effect of distortion, when you listen to enough low-quality vinyl rips of 90s emo bands turning from pin-dropping to full-on, crashing crescendos.
this is beyond lo-fi; it’s fail-fi. deliberately sabotaging every second of your music might be an interesting artistic statement - it might even sound exciting, for some - but I can’t help feeling it lacks the energy and integrity that comes from ‘honest’ music. not that there wasn’t some dishonesty in ripping off Slint and then screaming on top of it, but there was feeling.
(here’s agrammar on the topic of production and this Sleigh Bells song)

fleetfootedfox:

tristn:

“The final world-shattering salvo of the Loudness War”: Here’s the waveform of the first minute of Sleigh Bells “Crown on the Ground”.

Ohmygod.  It’s clipping-as-distortion-effect.

but clipping (or, at least, serious deterioration of sound quality) is already an effect of distortion, when you listen to enough low-quality vinyl rips of 90s emo bands turning from pin-dropping to full-on, crashing crescendos.

this is beyond lo-fi; it’s fail-fi. deliberately sabotaging every second of your music might be an interesting artistic statement - it might even sound exciting, for some - but I can’t help feeling it lacks the energy and integrity that comes from ‘honest’ music. not that there wasn’t some dishonesty in ripping off Slint and then screaming on top of it, but there was feeling.

(here’s agrammar on the topic of production and this Sleigh Bells song)

Comments (View) | 23 notes
  1. matt-byrne reblogged this from hardcorefornerds and added:
    dug up from a few weeks ago and reblogged for dylan.
  2. sunshadowpoet reblogged this from abloodymess and added:
    Excellent bringing this up, and Owen of course provided an excellent citation for this.
  3. car-vs-semi reblogged this from fuckyeahemo and added:
    The biggest failure of this is that digital clipping doesn’t create a “good” kind of distortion like analog recording...
  4. perpetualweirdo reblogged this from abloodymess and added:
    that song hurts.
  5. abloodymess reblogged this from hardcorefornerds and added:
    Bob Weston has a great bit about the whole loudness wars up on his mastering company’s website.
  6. fuckyeahemo reblogged this from hardcorefornerds and added:
    Crush, expand, crush, expand; louder, louder, louder; destruction, lifeless It destroys me
  7. hardcorefornerds reblogged this from blackbutshining and added:
    but clipping (or, at least, serious deterioration of sound quality) is already an effect of distortion, when you listen...
  8. superdoofus-stratodrive reblogged this from blackbutshining
blog comments powered by Disqus